Arrowhead Homes for Sale

Welcome to Arrowhead, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque landscape of Cimarron, Colorado, within the stunning Gunnison County. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of serene mountain living and modern convenience, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a peaceful retreat or a place to call home.

Arrowhead is characterized by its breathtaking views, with the majestic Rocky Mountains serving as a stunning backdrop. Residents enjoy a tranquil lifestyle, surrounded by nature's beauty, yet are just a short drive from the vibrant town of Gunnison, where you can find a variety of shops, restaurants, and recreational activities. Whether you’re an outdoor enthusiast eager to explore miles of hiking and biking trails, or someone who appreciates the beauty of the changing seasons, Arrowhead is the perfect place to immerse yourself in Colorado’s natural wonders.

The homes for sale in Arrowhead are as diverse as the landscape itself, offering a range of styles and sizes to suit every taste and budget. From cozy cabins to spacious family homes, each property is designed to maximize comfort and take advantage of the stunning surroundings. Many homes feature expansive decks, large windows, and open floor plans that invite the beauty of the outdoors in.

If you’re looking for a slice of Colorado paradise, Arrowhead is waiting for you. With its inviting community and exceptional properties, now is the perfect time to explore the homes for sale in this enchanting subdivision. Come discover your dream home in Arrowhead, where the beauty of nature meets the warmth of community.

Newest Arrowhead Homes for Sale

$775,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 837192 MLS

Exceptional furnished cabin in Arrowhead Ranch with breathtaking mountain views! This spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bath, 2675 sq ft cabin also includes a fifth non-conforming sleeping area, providing plenty of room for family and friends. The open floor plan features large windows that bring in an abundance of natural light and showcase the surrounding scenery, along with hardwood and custom flooring throughout. The fully equipped kitchen offers everything needed to move right in and start enjoying mountain living. Recent improvements include a new deck, light fixtures, window trim and shades, upstairs showers, faucets, bedding, rugs, towels, kitchenware, exterior staining, and added foam insulation around the stem wall, interior walls, and exterior windows. The garage is currently used for vehicle and recreational equipment storage, including ATVs and snowmobiles, but could easily be converted into a game and bar room for additional entertaining space. Outside, enjoy the new wraparound deck, patio furniture, and two firepit areas. Located in the private Arrowhead Ranch community near the Arrowhead Mountain Lodge, restaurant, summer concerts, and endless outdoor recreation. Seasonal winter access is available to the winter parking area, with snowmobile or tracked side-by-side access to the cabin. Located in Unit 66 for hunting.

60 Spruce Dr, Cimarron

$440,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 836777 MLS

Settled among towering aspens and pines, this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath mountain retreat offers the authentic Colorado cabin experience you've been searching for. Surrounded by mature trees and peaceful forest scenery, this property provides the perfect balance of comfort, privacy, and outdoor adventure. Located in the Arrowhead Subdivision in Cimarron CO. Step inside to soaring tongue-and-groove ceilings, exposed beams, and a stunning wall of windows that fills the great room with natural light while bringing the beauty of the outdoors inside. Warm wood finishes throughout create an inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements the mountain setting. The open-concept living, dining, and kitchen areas provide an ideal space for gathering with family and friends, while the spacious loft offers additional flexibility for guests, a home office, or recreation area. Large glass doors open to the expansive wraparound deck, for creating the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee, wildlife sightings, entertaining and peaceful evenings beneath the Colorado sky. Located in Game Management Unit 66 and just a short drive to Blue Mesa Reservoir and the Uncompahgre National Forest, this property offers year-round recreation including hunting, fishing, boating, hiking, ATV riding, and snowmobiling. Lake City is also not far to enjoy all the events that little town has to offer! Short Drive to Montrose or Gunnison for shopping or an airport. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, seasonal getaway, or recreational retreat, this exceptional cabin delivers the warmth, character, and mountain lifestyle that make Colorado living so special.

201 Lake Rd, Cimarron

$549,599

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 836078 MLS

If you are looking for a place to escape the hustle and bustle of busy life in the city, then this is the place for you! Escape to the peace and beauty of mountain living with this stunning 3 bed, 2.5 bath cabin retreat nestled on .72 acres surrounded by towering trees and breathtaking scenery. You will fall in love the moment you walk into this spacious and welcoming home, featuring a Great Room with floor-to-ceiling views and custom-plastered and painted walls that capture the beauty of the outdoors while filling the interior with natural light. Step outside to enjoy the incredible wraparound deck overlooking the gorgeous wooded and meadowed lot, perfect for relaxing, entertaining, or gathering around the outdoor fire pit under the stars. There's a hookup already installed for your camper, including 30-50 amp electrical, water, and sewage disposal. Inside, you'll find warm and inviting vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, and a cozy woodstove that creates the perfect mountain atmosphere. The main level primary suite offers a peaceful retreat complete with a jetted soaking tub, double sinks, a separate water closet, a large walk in closet, and spacious design details throughout. A beautiful upstairs railing overlooks the main living area and leads to two additional bedrooms, a bathroom with a shower, and an office area, adding both charm and functionality to the home's thoughtful layout. Well-designed features that make this an especially welcoming property include high ceilings, abundant storage, mudroom, separate laundry room, and private outdoor spaces. Fully furnished and ready to enjoy. This special location sits between Montrose and Gunnison, bordering public lands. Arrowhead offers you an endless list of outdoor recreation from: hunting, fishing, skiing, horseback riding, snowmobiling, ATVing, hiking, as well as biking. Daily wildlife appearances add to the serene and magical setting you'll enjoy year round. The Arrowhead Community offers a way of life that is unique and as part of community, you'll enjoy access to Arrowhead Mountain Lodge. The Lodge is a popular gathering spot that offers a restaurant, outdoor dining with live music during the summer months, as well as a bar. A great place for you, family, and friends to hang out after a day of exploring the Black Canyon, the Curecanti National Recreation Area, or maybe the Blue Mesa Reservoir. Luxury Resorts: Crested Butte and Telluride are just 1.5 - 2 hours away. If you need extra rooms for guests, there are Guest Rooms available at the Arrowhead Mountain Lodge. Call today for your private showing.

1380 Spruce Rd, Cimarron

$639,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 836038 MLS

Fully furnished mountain property located in the established Arrowhead community. The main home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, abundant natural light, and tongue and groove vaulted ceilings. The kitchen features brand new appliances that are included with the sale. The property also includes a detached oversized two-car garage featuring a 10’ x 8’ rear garage door with approximately 744 square feet of finished bonus space above, providing flexibility for a variety of uses. Situated on approximately 0.75 acres, the home offers a private, wooded setting with multiple decks for outdoor enjoyment. Recent improvements include Renewal by Andersen windows and doors installed in August 2024. Located within the Arrowhead community with access to private lakes/ponds, trails, and a lodge. Seasonal winter parking is available nearby. Polaris Expedition 1000 side-by-side and hot tub are negotiable.This is co listed with AEM Home, Jennifer Brown. MLS#8871364

861 Balsam Dr, Cimarron

$839,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 835100 MLS

Stunning Craftsman Custom Cabin/Mountain Home is located in Cimarron Colorado. Spanning 3 levels with primary bedroom located in the loft area over looking the spacious living area and views, this gem combines rustic with luxury in the heart of Arrowhead Subdivision. The main room has 28' vaulted T&G ceiling and oversized custom aspen trimmed windows. Kitchen has the very best stainless steel appliances with gorgeous custom cabinets and granite counter tops. Makes this spacious area, open floor plan an entertainers dream. The laundry room/ office area also has tons of custom cabinets for your storage. Stackable washer and dryer are also included in this package. This room acts as a mud room/office to kick off your shoes before you walk on the amazing tile and hardwood floors. Two guests rooms and full bath are located on the main level. Full guest bath has granite countertop, custom tiled shower with stone vessel sink. An added bonus is a balcony located off of 1 of the guest rooms to dosome wildlife watching. The lower level is quite cozy and large with its own pellet stove and couches. Makes a great movie room, or entertainment area as well. Flooring is stained/stamped insulated concrete. Nudura insulated forms were used to keep this room warm in the winter and cool in the summer. There is an attached work/storage/utility room that has built ins to provide for even more added storage. Navien high efficiency tankless water heater installed. Offers double doors to the outside for easy access to all your maintenance needs. Cabin comes 90% furnished with beautiful and custom furnishings. You just need to bring your toothbrush and food! Covered front Trex deck is an amazing place to sit outside and enjoy your secluded lot. Plenty of privacy for you to relax and unwind while getting away from the everyday hustle and bustle. There is even an outdoor fire pit with flagstone for you sit around with friends and family! Both front porch and carport (could be finished to a 1 car garage) finished in a T&G... no details have been missed on this exquisite cabin! This craftsmen's cabin/mountain home is located in the private community of Arrowhead Subdivision. Seasonal access, but don't let that stop you. There is Arrowhead Mountain Lodge that has a restaurant and is open year round forall outdoor enthusiasts. They also offer rentals for UTV's and snowmobiles. Invite your friends and family up during the summer months to enjoy the outdoor concerts and great food offered from the lodge! This cabin is located in Unit 66 for hunting and located just mins. from Blue Mesa or Gunnison River for all your fishing needs. Forgot to mention, Arrowhead also has 2 X-large ponds fully stocked for your fishing needs, no permit required. Cimarron Colorado is located not far from Crested Butte for skiing, Gunnison and Montrose for your shopping needs. There are somany outdoor activities to be done in the amazing area. This truly is a MUST See!

175 Aspen Trl, Cimarron

$695,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 833138 MLS

Settled among the pines and aspens, this one-owner mountain cabin is the kind of place that doesn’t come along often—and once you’re here, you won’t want to leave. Built with care and clearly loved and extremely maintained over the years, this property tells a story the moment you pull in. From the classic wood exterior and metal roof to the welcoming covered front and back porch, it delivers that true Colorado cabin feel buyers are chasing… but rarely find done this well. Step inside and you’re greeted by soaring tongue-and-groove ceilings, warm natural wood throughout, and a stunning floor-to-ceiling window wall that brings the outdoors right into your living space. The cozy wood stove, set against a stone backdrop, anchors the room perfectly. The layout offers comfortable living with multiple gathering spaces, including a spacious upper-level loft/flex area that’s perfect for additional sleeping, a game room, office, or a second living area. The kitchen is functional and inviting with ample cabinetry and counter space, flowing seamlessly into the dining area with access to the back deck—ideal for morning coffee or evening unwinding in the trees around the firepit and friends. Don't forget about the hot tub for early morning or late evening soaks. The primary bedroom offers its own private access to the outdoors and hot tub, creating a peaceful retreat feel, while the additional spaces provide flexibility for guests and family. There is a 3rd non-conforming bedroom with a murphy bed. Both guest rooms are upstairs for added privacy. Outside, the property really shines. A detached garage/shop gives you room for all the toys—whether it’s snowmobiles, ATVs, or gear for every season. There’s plenty of space to roam, relax, and take in the quiet that only a setting like this can offer. Located in Game Management Unit 66, known for elk, mule deer, bear, and more Just a short drive to Blue Mesa Reservoir for boating and salmon fishing Close access to Uncompahgre National Forest for endless outdoor adventure Winter access is maintained by the HOA to the main parking area, with snowmobile or tracked vehicle access beyond—adding to the true Colorado mountain experience. If you’ve been waiting for an authentic Colorado mountain retreat with character, warmth, and room to breathe… this is it.

200 Lake Rd, Cimarron

$870,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 828599 MLS

This 4-bedroom, 3-bath log cabin retreat in Arrowhead Ranch offers 3,015 square feet of living space and is ideal for entertaining or use as a short-term rental. The main level features a primary bedroom, laundry room, three-quarter bath, and a spacious living area with a beautiful kitchen that includes an induction cooktop, oven, dishwasher, and trash compactor. From the east deck, enjoy incredible views of Blue Mesa Reservoir to the northeast. On the west covered porch, enjoy the Colorado sunsets through the trees. Upstairs consists of a loft with additional sleeping space, an office area, a full bath, a playroom, and a large storage closet. The lower level provides a sitting area with TV, a game room with a pool table, a boiler room, a bedroom with a bath, and an unfinished steam shower setup and storage closets down the hall. This home comfortably sleeps nine and offers modern upgrades such as on-demand hot water, in-floor radiant heat, an induction fireplace in the lower suite, Starlink internet, and metal roofs throughout. The detached garage is designed with drive-through doors on each end, making it perfect for snowmobile or ATV storage. The property backs to open space on the east side, ensuring long-term privacy. The sellers will consider selling the home furnished and may also offer a 2023 Ranger XP 1000 with tracks, tires, and a full bed cover for the right price. Arrowhead Ranch is a 2,500-acre covenant-protected mountain community known for its one-acre lots, meadows, forests, creeks, and lakes. Residents enjoy private stocked lakes, underground utilities, a central water system, and Arrowhead Mountain Lodge for dining, drinks, and live entertainment. Outdoor recreation is endless with nearby hiking, UTV and side-by-side trails, hunting, and fishing. Blue Mesa Reservoir is just 20 minutes away, offering trophy fishing and boating opportunities. The sellers will be executing a 1031 exchange with this property.

160 Crest Dr, Cimarron

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2026. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to limited license rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited. FULL CREN Disclaimer Real Estate listings held by companies other than CREN contain that company's name. Fair Housing Disclaimer This data was last updated: